Comparison of the Paddy Drying Process and Milling Quality between Re-circulating and Conventional Batch Type Dryers

Document Type : Research Article

Authors

• H. R. Gazor ¹
• A. Moumeni ²

¹ Associate Professor, Agricultural Engineering Research Institute, Agricultural Research, Education and Extension Organization (AREEO), Karaj, Iran

² Rice Research Institute of Iran, Mazandaran branch, Agricultural Research, Education and Extension Organization (AREEO), Amol, Iran

https://doi.org/10.22067/jam.v9i2.72761

Abstract

Introduction
High energy consumption and non-uniformity drying in conventional batch type dryer are the common problems in paddy dying industry. Non-uniformity drying causes to kernel breaking chance in the milling process. Using new dryers with better performance can solve the drying problem and energy saving. In this research, the operation of a re-circulating batch dryer was compared with a fixed bed batch dryer (conventional dryer) for paddy drying.
Materials and Methods
This research was done in a paddy milling factory in Ferydonkenar and deputy of Rice Research Institute of Iran, in Amol, Mazandaran province. Both re-circulating dryer and conventional batch type dryer were made by Khazar Electric Company in Amol- Iran and they had 5 tonnes capacity. In the re-circulating dryer, ambient air was warmed in the furnace and blown to drying zone inside of grain bin. Natural Gas (NG) was used for air warming in dryers. Warm air absorbed paddy moisture and pushed away from the dryer. Drying temperature ranges for re-circulating dryer and conventional dryer was 48-50 °C and 38-52°C, respectively. The paddy variety was one of the Iranian rice varieties as Tarom and initial moisture content of grains was 21% (w.b), it was decreased using drying to 8-9% (w.b) for milling process. Paddy moisture content was measured each 60-120 min by SUNCUE TD-6 portable moisture tester-Taiwan. Energy consumption calculated by fuel and electrical energy summation in each experiment. Natural Gas and electrical power consumption were measured by Gas and electric counters respectively.
Drying time, paddy moisture change trend and energy consumption were investigated for paddy drying in each dryers. Also, milling ratio, breaking percent, whitening degree, and elongation rate after cooking were studied after the milling process for rice dried using national standard methods and deputy of Rice Research Institute facilities in Amol. Experimental samples were 150 g and husker (SATAKE THU35B), a whitener (SATAKE TMU05) and KETT C-100 were used for husking, whitening and whiteness degree, respectively. All Experiments were done with three replication and data analyzed using T- student method in 5% probability. 
Results and Discussion
Results showed that re-circulating dryer caused to reduce 54.12 percent in drying time and energy saving in paddy drying in compare with conventional paddy dryers. The trend of moisture content changes was longer and over-drying occurred in lower layers in conventional batch type dryer compared to re-circulating dryer. Paddy drying was 20 hours more in batch type than the re-circulating dryer. It caused wasting time and energy consumption. Specific energy consumption for water evaporating in the re-circulating batch dryer was 3.9 MJ/kg water and it was 76.25 percent less than fixed bed batch dryer.  After the drying process in both dryers, paddy moisture content was in range 8-9 percent (% w.b). Using re-circulating dryer did not have a significant effect on milling yield but it had a significant effect on broken rice. Broken rice decreased by 5 percent after the milling process when paddy dried by re-circulating. Uniformity of layers drying and normal heat stress in rice kernels in re-circulating dryer reduced broken rice in the milling process. Whiteness degree of rice dried using fixed bed dryer was 2.4 percent more than the re-circulating batch dryer. Also, rice dried had more elongation rate about 6.2 percent after cooking when paddy dried by conventional dryer. 
Conclusion
Results of this paper showed that using of re-circulating dryer would decrease time and modify energy consumption in paddy drying. The costs of installation for the re-circulating batch dryer was about 5.3 times more than fixed bed batch dryer. It seems too expensive at first but considering energy and time-saving in the drying process and suitable effect on decreasing grain breakage in paddy milling, using of the re-circulating batch dryer is recommendable in rice milling factories.

Keywords

• Drying
• Energy
• Paddy
• Re-circulating dryer
• Rice milling

20.1001.1.22286829.1398.9.2.9.0

References

1. Anonymous. 2001. Rice- Specification and test methods. National standard No. 127. Industrial research and standard of Iran. Karaj. (In Farsi).

2. Anonymous. 2003. Moisture measurement. Unground Grain and seed. ASAE standards, S352.2, FEB03, pp. 593.

3. Bakker Arkema, F. W., C. Fontana, and I. P. Schiscler. 1983. Comparison of rice dry systems. ASAE, Paper No. 83-3532.

4. Basunia, M. A., and T. Abe. 1998. Diffusion coefficients for predicting rough rice drying behavior from low to high temperatures. International Agricultural Engineering Journal 7 (3-4): 147-158.

5. Bhattacharya, K. R. 1980. Breakage of rice during milling. A Review, Trop. Sci. 22: 225.

6. Billiris, M. A. 2013. Measuring the energy required to dry rice in commercial rice dryers. Theses and Dissertations. University of Arkansas, Fayetteville.

7. Billiris M. A., T. J. Siebenmorgen, and G. L. Baltz. 2014 Energy used and efficiency of drying systems I. on-farm cross-flow dryer measurements. Applied Engineering in Agriculture 30 (2): 205-215.

8. Brooker, D. B., F. W. Baker Arkema, and C. W. Hall. 1992. Drying and storage of grains and oilseeds. AVI Book publisher, New York , U.S.A.

9. Fan, J., T. J. Siebenmorgen, and W. Yang. 2000. A study of head rice yield reduction of long and medium grain rice varieties in relation to various harvest and drying conditions. Trans. of the ASAE. 43 (6): 1709-1714.

10. Gazor, H. R. 2014. Investigation and comparison of losses and energy consumption in conventional and modern rice milling systems (Mazandaran Province report). Research report No. 45922. Agricultural engineering research institute. Karaj. (In Farsi).

11. Habibi, F., and A. YahyaZadeh. 2015. Evaluation of Amylose and Amylopectin Structure on Quality of Iranian Rice. Journal of Agricultural Engineering Research 16 (2): 61-70. (In Farsi).

12. Jittanit, W., N. Saeteaw, and A. Charoenchaisri. 2010. Industrial paddy drying and energy saving options. Journal of Stored Products Research 46: 209-213.

13. Kent, N. L. 1982. Technology of cereals an introduction for students of food science and agriculture. Third edition. P: 185.

14. Khostaghaza, M. H., M. Solymani, and M. Shahedi. 2002. Correlation of head rice yield (HRY) with rough rice fissuring and bending strength in drying process. Iranian. Journal of Agricultural Science 33 (1):115-121. (In Farsi).

15. Khoshtaghaza, M. H., M. Sadeghi, and R. Amirichayjan. 2007. Study of rough rice drying process in fixed and fluidized bed conditions. Journal of Agricultural Sciences and Natural Resources 14 (2). (In Farsi).

16. Kiyanmehr, M., T. Tavakoli, and M. H. Khoshtaghaza. 2001. Effect of temperature and air velocity on drying time and paddy moisture content in batch type dryer. Journal of Agricultural Science 9 (1): 17-29. (In Farsi).

17. Kocsis L., I. Keppler, M. Herdovics, L. Fenyvesi, and I. Farkas. 2011. Investigation of moisture content fluctuation in mixed flow dryer. Agronomy Research Biosystem Engineering, Special Issue 1: 99-105.

18. Latifi, A. 2011. Effect of drying temperature and paddy final moisture on milling quality of three rice varieties. Agronomy Journal (Pajouhesh & Sazandegi) 102: 71-75. (In Farsi).

19. Mousavi, S. F., M. H. Abbaspour-Fard, M. Khojastehpour. 2015. The effect of fan speed control system on the inlet air temperature uniformity in a solar dryer. Journal of Agricultural Machinery 5 (2): 491-50. (In Farsi).

20. Omar, S. J., and R. Yamashita. 1987. Rice drying husking and milling. Part Ι: Drying. Agricultural mechanization in Asia- Africa and Latin America 18 (2): 43-46.

21. Peyman, M. H. 2003. Losses in rice milling (hulling and whitening). Training workshop. Agricultural Agriculture College of Gilan University, Rasht. (In Farsi).

22. Rafiee, Sh., and A. Tabatabifar. 2005. Effect of depth of batch-type dryer on rice losses during rough rice processing operation. Proceeding of the second national conference on losses of agricultural products, pages 483-491. (In Farsi).

23. Reid, J. D., T. J. Siebenmorgen, and J. Fan. 1997. The effects of variety, harvest location, harvest moisture content and drying air conditions on rough rice drying parameters. ASAE annual international meeting, Minneapolis, Minesota, USA, paper No: 976069.

24. Rumsey, T. R. and C. O. Rovedo. 2001. Two-dimensional simulation model for dynamic cross flow rice drying. Chemical Engineering and Processing 40: 355-362.

25. Sitompul, J. P., I. Stadi, and S. Sumardiono. 2003 Modeling and Simulation of Momentum, Heat, and Mass Transfer in a Deep-Bed Grain Dryer. Drying Technology 21: 217-229.

26. Soleymani, M. 1998. Effects of dryer parameters on rice quality parameters and breaking. Master of Science thesis in food science and industries. Tarbiat modaress University. 190 pages. (In Farsi).

27. Soponronnarit, S., and S. Chinsakoltanakorn. 1986. Energy consumption patterns in drying paddy by various drying strategies. In: Soponronnarit, S. (Ed.) Proceedings of a Regional Seminar on Alternative Energy Applications in Agriculture, 27-29 October 1986, Chiang Mai University, Thailand, p 14.

28. Tajaddoditalab, K. 2013. Effect of dryer temperature, final paddy moisture content and whitener on head rice and cooking quality of some Iranian rice varieties. Research report No. 44952. Rice research Institute of Iran. (In Farsi).

29. Teter, N. 1987. Paddy drying manual. FAO of the United Nations, Rome.

30. Wongpornchai, S., K. Dumri, S. Jongkaewwattana, and B. Siri. 2004. Effects of drying methods and storage time on the aroma and milling quality of rice (Oryza sativa L.) cv. KhaoDawk Mali 105. Food Chemistry 87 (3): 407-414.

31. Zamani, Gh. and M. R. Alizadeh. 2009. Introducing of Iranian rice. Malek Pub. Tehran. (In Farsi).